top of page

The 81st UNGA and Africa’s future in the international legal order

Writer: ACIL
ACIL
Nov 5
6 min read

Written by Mahad Kisuze Mugaya


Africa at the UN

As is the case every year, the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) convened at UN Headquarters in New York towards the end of September. This year’s assembly was the 81st since the creation of the United Nations in 1945. At the time of the creation of this apex international body, the status of the majority of the world was far different from what it is like today. In fact, only four states from the African continent participated in the adoption of the UN Charter at the San Francisco Conference. This is less than even a tenth of the number of states on the continent today.


The theme for this year’s General Assembly was “Restoring Trust, Managing Transformation: A United Nations That Delivers for All” and for several days presidents and representatives of member states and multilateral organisations took the podium to deliver speeches that reflected the positions of their states on some of the most pressing contemporary global issues. At the centre of the majority of the speeches and sideline conversations between states were issues to do with artificial intelligence, climate change, wars and inequality. António Guterres, the UN Secretary-General, in his final UNGA address also stressed these issues as the defining tests for the future of the world today. My focus is on the issue of inequality because I believe that it will shape how the other three issues are addressed.


Africa and the Security Council


The United Nations is built on a foundational principle of the sovereign equality of states. This is the logic behind Article 2 of the UN Charter that protects the sovereignty of all states and prohibits the unilateral use of force by states against the territorial integrity or political independence of other states. One would assume that the import of this is that the international legal institutions should have equality in the way they are constituted and how they function. However, this is not the position, and a question of equality has been lingering over the principal organs of the United Nations since the time of its creation in 1945. The UN Security Council is the enforcement body of the UN which was given broad powers under the UN Charter, including the primary responsibility for the maintenance of international peace and security, the authority to impose sanctions, and the power to authorise the use of force by states. The UN Security Council is composed of 15 members, five of whom are permanent members with veto powers whereas the other ten members do not have veto powers and are elected by the General Assembly for two-year terms. None of the permanent members of the Security Council is an African state. The question of equal representation of the world on the UN Security Council has therefore put into sharp contrast the glaring inequality of the international legal order in its current state. In fact, equal representation of African states on the UN Security Council was one of the most spoken-about issues during the recently concluded UNGA session. The UN Secretary-General described the absence of a permanent African member on the Security Council as unjust and indefensible in the current day and age.


Going by the speeches at the recently concluded UNGA, there is now clear momentum across a majority of states for the acceptance of permanent African membership on the UN Security Council to address the inequality that arises from the historical under-representation of Africa on the Council. This is no mean task because the route for this to happen is the amendment of the UN Charter under Article 108. Such an amendment can be commenced by a motion moved by any member state but for it to be adopted, it requires the support of a two-thirds majority in the UN General Assembly, including the affirmative votes of all the existing five permanent members of the UN Security Council. A negative vote from any of the five permanent members would jeopardise the amendment. One would then ask whether all of these five permanent members are willing to share their special status with other additional member states. The other question is whether 97 or more member states are ready to support such an amendment. I think this illustrates the nature of the uphill task that this is, requiring political will from the UN member states including all the five permanent members. This political will can only be attained by targeted lobbying of the five permanent member states and of the broader membership of the UN. The next question that then flows from this is whether Africa is ready for this heavy task, which brings me to my second point.


The Secretary-General Race


I think the first lobbying spear that Africa has to throw towards this amendment is in the ongoing process for the selection of the next United Nations Secretary-General. António Guterres’ second and last term ends on 31 December 2026. The selection process that is now underway is one of the most consequential decisions that the UN will take this year. The choice of who occupies the office of UN Secretary General has consequences for the African dream to have permanent seats at the UN Security Council. Whereas the UN Secretary-General does not possess any formal power to force an amendment of the Charter, the office carries substantial moral and soft power in the diplomatic world and under the UN Charter system. Therefore, a Secretary-General who treats African permanent representation as a non-negotiable priority can help to influence the decision of the five permanent members and the other member states in general. In this regard, it is in the interests of the African states to have a unified position on who should become the next Secretary-General. Such a candidate should be one that has the idea of an amendment of the UN Charter to address the under-representation of Africa among their priorities. Naturally, I think nobody would fit this description more than an African Secretary-General.


African states initially fielded two candidates in this race, which divided the support of the continent. Former Senegalese President Macky Sall, nominated by Burundi, withdrew his candidacy on 17 October 2026 after successive informal Security Council straw polls revealed limited encouragement and a clear preference among many members for a candidate from the Latin American and Caribbean region. This left Uganda’s Olara Otunnu, a veteran diplomat and former UN Under-Secretary-General and Special Representative for Children in Armed Conflict, as the sole remaining African candidate. The test in this is whether Africa can, through this Secretary-General race, demonstrate the organisational seriousness that is required to mount a sustained push for an amendment of the UN Charter. A consensus or selection of a Secretary-General who pays attention to the African agenda will smooth the process. Only after that consensus is secured should the continent turn its full efforts to the more contentious question of the two permanent seats at the UN Security Council.


The race has really highlighted the structural problems Africa is up against. In the recent informal straw polls the Security Council has been running, some of them even colour-coded to show who permanent members might veto, every candidate including Otunnu has at some point attracted ‘discourage’ votes from one or more of the permanent members. These dynamics drive home the bigger lesson from the 81st UNGA which is that without greater unity of purpose and real strategic coordination among African states, even the strong moral case for reform of the UN Security Council is going to struggle to turn into actual institutional change.


I think that Africa has more homework to do in agreeing on which states will take up the two permanent seats at the UN Security Council. The Ezulwini Consensus did not resolve this question of which specific African states should occupy those seats. It is also a question that is still lingering. The choice of countries to take up these positions will also have a huge impact on whether the other member states of the UN support the decision to amend the UN Charter or not.


Conclusion


Africa has the mantle and moral authority to lead the charge to solve the challenge of inequality starting from the representation of the continent in the UN Security Council. There has never been a better time for this. However, this can only be achieved through targeted diplomatic efforts by member states in the African bloc, beginning with the demonstration of seriousness and unity in the current Secretary-General selection process and continuing into a clear, AU-driven consensus on the occupants of any future permanent seats.


Comments


  • LinkedIn
  • X
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
bottom of page